See Ya March!
1. Question – If everything is meaningless, does
that mean that that statement has no validity?
2. Thought – I recall an exchange I once had on the
campus of the University of the Philippines in Manila. A
student from the audience shouted out that everything in
life was meaningless. I responded by saying, “You do
not believe that.” He promptly retorted, “Yes,
I do,” to which I automatically countered,
“No, you don’t.” Exasperated, he said,
“I most certainly do; who are you to tell me I
don’t?” “Then please repeat your
statement for me,” I requested. “Everything in
life is meaningless,” he stated again without
qualification. I said to him, “Please remain
standing; this will only take a moment. I assume that you
believe your statement is meaningful. If your statement is
meaningful then everything is not meaningless. On the
other hand, if everything is meaningless, then what you
just said is meaningless too. So in effect you have said
nothing.” The young man was startled for a moment
and even as I left the auditorium, he was pacing the floor
muttering, “If everything is meaningless,
then….” So it went!
“There are three things that must go right with
any argument:
-
The terms must be unambiguous
-
The premises must be true
-
The argument must be logical” (Beyond Opinion by Ravi Zacharias)
Goodbye Sampa!